The world of Gotham City continues to expand, and this time it’s without Batman at the forefront. The Penguin, an eight-part HBO series set in the gritty world established by Matt Reeves’ The Batman, promises a deep dive into the criminal underworld. This spin-off brings Oswald “Oz” Cobblepot to the center of attention, following his rise to power after the chaos caused by The Riddler. But does this show stand on its own without the Caped Crusader? Let’s take a look.
A Character-Driven Story with Stellar Performances
At the heart of The Penguin 2024 is Colin Farrell’s phenomenal portrayal of Oswald Cobblepot. Hidden beneath layers of makeup, Farrell disappears into the role, making Oz both a terrifying villain and an oddly sympathetic figure. His performance is gritty, intense, and utterly captivating, transforming a character often treated as a caricature into a complex anti-hero.
Farrell’s Penguin is cunning, ruthless, and deeply ambitious. His rise to power is driven by a desire for respect, and he knows how to use his enemies’ underestimation of him to his advantage. Farrell’s version of the Penguin draws comparisons to iconic mob figures like Tommy DeVito from Goodfellas and Tony Soprano, and his performance elevates the show to new heights.
A Gotham Without Batman
One of the most intriguing aspects of The Penguin 2024 is how it manages to create a compelling narrative in Batman’s absence. The Dark Knight is only mentioned once throughout the series, yet his presence looms large over the proceedings. Gotham is still reeling from the destruction caused by The Riddler, and the power vacuum left behind gives Oz the perfect opportunity to seize control of the city’s underworld.
However, this is not just a story about crime—it’s about power, ambition, and the dangerous line between villain and anti-hero. Oz’s journey is deeply personal, particularly in his relationship with his dementia-stricken mother, Francis. He craves her approval and hides her from the world, promising a life of wealth and luxury once he has claimed his place atop Gotham’s crime hierarchy.
Gritty Visuals and Atmospheric Storytelling
The Penguin 2024 stays true to the dark, atmospheric tone set by Reeves’ The Batman. Directed by Craig Zobel, known for his work on Mare of Easttown, the series immerses viewers in a world of shadows, rain-soaked streets, and decaying cityscapes. The red-tinged gloom that encases Gotham perfectly matches the dark, violent, and morally complex story being told.
In keeping with this aesthetic, the show’s pacing is deliberate, focusing more on character development and psychological depth than high-octane action. Yet, when the action does unfold, it’s brutal and unrelenting, reinforcing the danger and stakes at play in Gotham’s criminal landscape.
The Rise of Oswald Cobblepot
The core of the series revolves around Oz’s rise in the aftermath of Carmine Falcone’s death. His ambition to take over Gotham’s underworld leads him into conflict with several formidable adversaries, including Falcone’s son, Alberto, and his ruthless sister, Sofia, played by Cristin Milioti. Sofia, freshly released from Arkham Asylum, is a force to be reckoned with, and her violent, unpredictable nature makes her a perfect foil for Oz.
As Oz works to manipulate both Sofia and Salvatore Maroni, another key player in Gotham’s crime world, he navigates a dangerous path, relying on his wit and cunning to survive. Farrell’s Penguin may be ambitious, but he is also clever enough to avoid unnecessary risks, knowing that his rivals could end his rise at any moment.
Compelling New Characters
In addition to Oz, The Penguin 2024 introduces a host of interesting characters, including Vic, a young thief who Oz recruits as his driver and protégé. Their relationship, based on shared experiences of growing up in Gotham’s slums, brings a surprising depth to the series. Vic’s youthful naivety contrasts with Oz’s hardened cynicism, adding a layer of humanity to the story.
At the same time, Sofia Falcone, dubbed “The Hangman” for her violent crimes, is one of the show’s most chilling characters. Her presence injects a sense of unpredictability, as she challenges Oz’s plans at every turn, making it clear that Gotham’s underworld is far from under his control.
Themes of Class Resentment and Power Struggles
One of the most compelling elements of The Penguin 2024 is its exploration of class resentment. Oz’s rise to power is fueled not just by his ambition but by his deep-seated anger toward Gotham’s elite. He grew up being looked down upon, and now he seeks revenge by taking what he believes is rightfully his.
Throughout the series, this theme of class struggle is ever-present, as Oz manipulates others who share his feelings of resentment to do his bidding. He uses the anger of the overlooked and ignored to build his empire, all while masking his own vulnerabilities behind a ruthless exterior.
Final Thoughts: A Dark and Captivating Journey
The Penguin 2024 is a bold and thrilling exploration of one of Gotham’s most iconic villains. Colin Farrell’s standout performance anchors the show, bringing a level of intensity and complexity that keeps viewers hooked from start to finish. Though Batman remains absent, the show thrives on its own, offering a gripping tale of crime, power, and the dark side of Gotham City.
Whether you’re a fan of Batman lore or simply enjoy dark, character-driven dramas, The Penguin 2024 is a must-watch. It stands tall as a worthy addition to the Gotham universe, with its own unique story to tell.
